Thanks to everyone who's weighed in on this. The gentleman who sold me the 14"s swears he used one as a spare on his Jag when he got into a pinch, so that's why one of the four was dirty. When I took it to Merchant's Tire they tried to mount a 14" Defender GRNX but it wouldn't fit. Installer told me it was a 15". Called seller back and he was sure it was a 14" so I took the rim to Sears and waited 30 minutes to have a "technician" tell me it was definitely a 16"!!! (he took a tape and measured from edge to edge, not kidding) Thoroughly disgusted, I stopped by a different Merchant's on the way home and showed that tech one of the shiny, new rims. There, printed on the side was "15 x 7" Mystery solved.
Peter, thanks for sharing your current tire's #'s. What is the difference between a 205/60/15 and a 205/65/15? One is about $12 a tire cheaper.
Hauser, dumb question, but how do I tell if the rear is centered? Aren't they all?
Since the stock wheels were 14 x 6, would the 15 x 7's affect anything being an inch wider?
Thanks, again for all the help.