OK, that's interesting. Are you sure it's not a loose fit in the bore hole? You may be putting a narrow WRD is a large bore hole. The geometry that interacts with the pump control is different too. One WRD has a much longer stroke than the other over its heat range. The offset (distance from the flange face to WRD tip) might be different too, but I've never checked.
The bottom line is that it won't work.