... and ah yes,
You guys are all correct, somehow...
The passenger door grab handle was black (or dark grey) on all 230 SLs up to VIN 012466. Thereafter (all other pagodas after VIN 012467)it was matching the interior color. There were a couple of colors available for these door handles, perhaps 10 or so but surely not 23 like (all) available leather interior paint codes.
If you want to recreate yours with the correct outfit, dont't cover it with the matching vinyl or leather, but use vinyl paint instead.
Sorry Ed,
you have an outstanding beautiful car, absolutely! But certainly your handle was taken from your old door panel which was previously covered with black MB tex - thus the black handle. With the new parchment (Pergament) leather it should have a (somehow) matching color.
Best,
Achim
(1964 230 with black interior and (faded) black door handle)