I also struggled with the question: what is the best fuel for our cars? If I ask experts, I get different answers. Since leaded fuel isn't available anymore in Holland for many years, the only option is unleaded fuel of course. But which one? Here we can choose between unleaded 95 or 98. But there are also "special" fuels like Shell V-power and BP Ultimate.
One mechanic advised me to use BP Ultimate. This fuel has some cleaning qualities. They claim that this fuel cuts away deposits in the engine, especially in older cars. See
http://www.bp.com/genericarticle.do?categoryId=9009378&contentId=7024182.
It sounded reasonable to me and last year I only bought BP Ultimate. My thought was: the extra cost for this fuel is always less than any repair to the engine.
The engine runs great on it. But I can't say that I have now a better engine performance or better mileage, that was not my objective. It's only the preservation of the engine and perhaps it also saves the injection pump.
Another mechanic advised me to use a unleaded fuel additive. I didn't use that so far, but I don't know if I should.
What are your thoughts?
Martijn