Happy New Year to all!
This period of the year is the anniversary of the purchase of my Pagoda. I usually take it for a spin on the first of January to remember that day when a winning bid made me the happy owner of a Pagoda after having looked for the right one for quite a while. This year though, I couldn’t drive it on the first of January as I spent Christmas and New Year’s Eve in Europe with family and friends.
This was not without some car action though, as I had the pleasure to drive the very nice BMW 3.0 CSI I co-own with a friend. I also had the occasion to drive his very nice Porsche 964.
I hadn’t driven the CSI in several years. This time, I was able to sort out an issue the car has had for a while. Someone must have tried to adjust the idle by using the throttle body stop screw. The result was that the Throttle Position Sensor was not contacting at idle and the car was idling like crap. Also the ECU kept-on supplying fuel on coasting, with a result of strong unburned gas smell each time this happened. All this is now sorted and the car runs as smoothly as ever with a nice steady idle.
The CSI has long been a benchmark for me regarding cars of that era. I find it quite modern in the way it drives. EFI really has it run very nicely and smoothly compared to carbed versions. The car is well planted on the road and quite securing. It is a very homogenous car. The CSI is also the culprit for taking me away from the MB 6 cylinder engine originally found in the Pagoda. That BMW M30 engine is so addictive, its howl so mesmerizing that I couldn’t really content myself anymore with the M130 which sounds a bit like a sewing machine in comparison (but that’s just my opinion of course!).
How does the CSI compare with my Pagoda in its V8 iteration? Well, this is where I realized how much improved the Pagoda is. Before the engine transplant and suspension upgrades the Pagoda’s older design was really relegating it into an older generation of cars compared to the CSI. It was looser on the road, and its performance was really lower. Now things are reversed. The Pagoda is much quicker and feels quite tighter on the road. Both cars however can compare by their balance and homogeneity. But the Pagoda is in another league now.
I had never driven a rear engine Porsche before. The 3.6 L is really a fantastic motor. It is very smooth, and pulls without any hesitation up to the red line. It can be described as some sort of rubber band effect. The car is extremely tight on the road, and clutch, steering, suspension and shifting are very firm, not to say harsh. I find it to be quite contrasting with the engine smoothness, to the point I feel the car not to be that homogenous in terms of driving pleasure. The other strange thing is that one is driving very close to the front wheels, and the feeling at each change of direction is a bit the same as the one felt in a van (on steroids though, and closer to the ground). Of course, Porsches are very peculiar cars, and I’m sure with a bit of adaptation time one must find it an exhilarating car.
How does the 964 compare with my Pagoda? I think the Pagoda has a bit more power, and quite a lot more torque earlier in the rpm range. Where the Pagoda jumps ahead from 2000 rpm, one would have to downshift with the Porsche to keep up. The Porsche, however, pulls effortlessly a bit higher in the rpm range. The Porsche also feels a bit harsher on the road, and I find my Pagoda can be driven with less effort. I must admit I don’t understand why the clutch is that harsh on the Porsche as it is obviously not needed: my Pagoda has quite a higher amount of torque and the clutch is much softer without slipping for that. How would both cars compare on a track? I think the Porsche would be ahead on the twisty bits, but the Pagoda would have the advantage on the faster bits. As a reference, the Pagoda could keep up with a 996 on the NCCAR track, as reported here:
http://www.sl113.org/forums/index.php?topic=15521.msg147912#msg147912 In the end, I think driving skills would make the difference and I’m not sure I would have the advantage over my friend who is an excellent driver and a very fast one when he goes at it.
Below are some pictures of both the BMW and the Porsche taken after a cold night.