First up I want to say happy xmas to all you guys. Its been a pretty up and down year for me but one positive constant is the help and support I have had from you all. So a big thanks and xmas wishes to you all
Have spent a good morning with the family unwrapping gifts and partaking in far too much food. No doubt this will continue for the rest of the day. I will have plenty of stored energy to tackle the engine start in the coming days.
I have been thinking about this crank bolt and considering what everyone has offered. Also been thinking back to another recent thread about one of our members who damaged the pins and pin housings on the front of the crank. Makes sense it had turned into an absolute nightmare to fix.
In relation to this front bolt and the technique to tighten it I am worried if I employ the technique of holding the damper rather than the crank that all the load would be applied to the two tiny dowel pins holding the damper to the crank. If they sheared or started to oval the crankshaft holes then I could be in for a world of hurt.
The factory technique of holding the crank rather than the damper makes more sense to me. As you tighten the large crank bolt down on the damper the turning load on the pins would surely be less as the body which your trying to screw the bolt into cannot turn and is taking the brunt. The other way around when your clamping force of the bolt bears down on the damper it will turn. If it is prevented but the crank can turn freely then in my mind all the force is going to bear on the dowels.
I am not an engineer so may be well out of line here. Feel free to buzz in.
I think the latter version went to a woodruff key which perhaps were better placed to accept the 200nm of force required to torque it up.
I am so close to starting my engine its not funny and this last little xmas curve ball needs to be 'safely' overcome. At this stage my gut tells me the factory type tool Kampala and tel76 are talking about is the way to go. This will probably me a lengthy delay for me.
I am quite flabbergasted that Mercedes made it so hard to do this as to conduct the routine maintenance of replacing the main crank seal this bolt would have to come off and on during the operation. It seems quite long winded to have to take the starter motor out to do this. I am as always interested to know if this was a design flaw that they rectified on the M130.