Actually, I think all the rhetoric published by various "wax" and "polish" companies is a lot like women's make-up, hair conditioners, shampoo's.
Bottom line on which to use or which is "best" or provides the "highest shine" is all pretty subjective as far as I can find on the web. I think the $150 type prices for the "exotic" wax's advertised for a 6 oz. container is a little more than absurd, frankly. I purchase and use far more complex chemicals that are only produced in extremely small volumes (almost prototype samples) for high tech applications in the range of $6-$10/cc (cubic cm) ... which for a 6 oz. container would come to something on the order of less than $100. To think that a container of a mixture of natural or synthetic waxes in suspension form would cost 50% more is laughable.
The chemical purchase price of pure carnuba was is less than $2/oz ($31/lb) by one supplier....
http://www.sciencelab.com/page/S/PVAR/SLC2764?gclid=CIODuMK_pYgCFSb-YAodSy-QVg... and less than $0.60/oz by another (16 oz. order), or less than $0.02/oz in 25 lb orders...
http://www.libertynatural.com/bulk/837.htmThis is an example of you don't always get what you pay for.
Here's a statement from a car-care company about Carnauba wax:
"Getting Acquainted with Natural Waxes
Natural wax is typically engineered from a substance called Carnauba. This wax is derived from the tropical plant called Copernica Cerifera and is as hard as a brick in its natural form. Because of the natural repellency of wax, this Brazilian plant is able to direct water flow from rainfall to its root structure. Many forms of flora have relied on natural wax to protect them from life threatening viruses, and you will find that it is equally useful in shielding your paint from contaminants. It should also be noted that natural wax is breathable: another plus for your paintjob. Companies that advertise bold statements such as ‘Contains 100% Carnauba Wax!’ are referring to the purity of the carnauba wax contained in the product, not the product as a whole. Without the addition of naphtha, petroleum distillates and other oils, this product would not be smooth enough to work its wonders on your vehicle. Therefore, the highest actual amount of carnauba in any given concoction is a delicate balance between many positive factors, and because of carnaubas natural denseness, only about 30% of it can fit workably into a product. Carnauba itself is harvested in Brazil, and different levels of purity exist. Yellow wax is reputably the highest achievable grade of wax available, and is used by the highest paying industries."
http://superiorcarcare.net/which-wax-is-best.htmlNow... Zymol's wax is 33% Carnauba wax selling on the web at the rate of for $5.75/oz ($46/8 oz jar). On a pro-rated basis, the carnauba content in this product costs over $16/oz!!!! or roughly on the order of 800x the bulk cost of the pure #1 Yellow Carnauba wax.... just to give some insight into how much hype's included in the price when the wax contains 'carbauba wax'.
Here's more on what's in Zymol's product though...
"- Formulated from a combination of nutritive waxes and oils, including 33% rare Brazilian no. 1 yellow carnauba wax content.
- Zymöl Creame Wax relies on the durable nature of carnauba wax to provide stellar paint protection.
- Contains No. 1 yellow carnauba wax (derived from palmetto), montan oil, coconut oil, banana oil, propolis (derived from bees), cetyl esters, cetyl cocoamide (derived from coconut oil) and FD&C blue #1
- Zymöl Creame Wax is sold in a long-lasting 8oz. jar.
- Zymöl Creame Wax is founded on a high concentration of rare yellow no. 1 Brazilian carnauba—33%, in fact. This fine carnauba, the most scarce and brilliant natural variety, works to enhance the depth of your light finish with the accompaniment of nurturing oils and esters. ...."
http://www.autoanything.com/car-care/69A3062A0A0.aspxNow look up what's in Turtle Wax's premium product... just for comparison purposes.
Natural waxes and other synthetic waxes are all some form of a fatty acid... all simple long chained carbon-hydrogen molecules.... the longer the chain the higher the volatility and higher the melting point in general, which is why, for example, Carnuba wax is harder and more resistant to water than Beeswax.... it's a longer chained fatty acid.
They all oxidize at about the same rate, all are "eaten" .... see my prior post.... by UV incident energy at about the same rate in any practical application, so the major differences are in concentrations of which waxes are included and what the emulsifier's are. Carnuba wax is used in larger volumes for food additives and inks than it will ever be used as an automobile surface treatment, so production of Carnuba wax from Natural sources isn't the determinate of the cost of the wax.... I'd say uninformed consumer's and marketing hype is the primary determinate of the price of a given "premium" car wax... just my opinion though.
Full disclosure... I use McGuire's high end product on my SL's... but I used Turtle wax and some synthetic's too... I can't really see much difference... some, but considering the time spent on McGuires application and the others, the difference in appearance might be discounted by spending twice as much wax and time on the cheaper varieties.
Remember that the UV exposure will kill the wax finish anyway in about the same amount of time for any wax product containing or using carnauba wax.
Longtooth
67 250SL US #113-043-10-002163
'02 SL500 Sport